The digital media rollup plan is useless

When a wedding or an engagement fails, it is common for the individuals to take time to work on themselves.

That is the place the digital media business finds itself at the moment.

After years of specializing in consolidating to raised compete with Google and Fb for digital promoting {dollars}, most of the most well-known digital media corporations have deserted consolidation efforts to focus on differentiation.

“What you are discovering is corporations are looking for a non-substitutable core,” mentioned Jonathan Miller, the CEO of Built-in Media, which makes a speciality of digital media investments. “The period of attempting to place these corporations collectively is over, and I do not assume it is coming again.”

A 90% decline in BuzzFeed shares for the reason that firm went public in 2021, a failed gross sales course of from Vice, the collapse of particular function acquisition corporations, and a uneven promoting market have made digital media executives rethink their corporations’ futures. For the second, executives have determined that extra concentrated funding is healthier than makes an attempt to achieve scale.

“Proper now, everybody’s attempting to get via a harder market by specializing in their strengths,” BuzzFeed CEO Jonah Peretti mentioned in an interview with CNBC. “We’re on this interval now the place we must always simply deal with innovating for the long run and constructing extra environment friendly, stronger, higher corporations.”

What’s taking place within the digital media area echoes traits from the largest media corporations, together with Netflix, Disney and Warner Bros. Discovery. After dropping almost half their market values, or extra, in 2022, these corporations have emphasised what makes them completely different, whether or not or not it’s distribution, model or high quality of programming, after years of world growth and mega-mergers. Disney CEO Bob Iger mentioned the phrase “model” greater than 25 instances at a Morgan Stanley media convention this month.

“I believe manufacturers matter,” Iger mentioned. “The extra selection individuals have, the extra essential manufacturers turn out to be due to what they convey to shoppers.”

Making strategic selections based mostly on client demand moderately than investor strain is a pivot for the business, mentioned Bryan Goldberg, CEO of Bustle Digital Group, which has acquired and developed quite a lot of manufacturers and websites geared toward ladies, together with Nylon, Scary Mommy, Romper and Elite Every day.

“Too most of the mergers had been pushed by investor wants versus client wants,” Goldberg mentioned in an interview.

From late 2018 to early 2022, the digital media business had a shared purpose. Pushed by enterprise capitalist and personal fairness traders who had made sizeable investments within the business in the course of the 2010s, corporations equivalent to BuzzFeed, Vice, Vox Media, Group 9, and Bustle Digital Group, or BDG, had been speaking to one another, in numerous mixtures, about merging to achieve scale.

“If BuzzFeed and 5 of the opposite greatest corporations had been mixed into a much bigger digital media firm, you’ll in all probability be capable to receives a commission more cash,” Peretti instructed The New York Occasions in November 2018, kicking off a multiyear effort to consolidate.

The rationale was twofold. First, digital media corporations wanted extra scale to compete with Fb and Google for digital promoting {dollars}. Including websites and types below one company umbrella would enhance general eyeballs for advertisers. Value-cutting from M&A synergies was an additional advantage for traders.

Second, longtime shareholders wished to exit their investments. Giant legacy media corporations equivalent to Disney and Comcast‘s NBCUniversal invested a whole lot of thousands and thousands in digital media within the early and mid-2010s. Disney invested greater than $400 million in Vice. NBCUniversal put an analogous quantity into BuzzFeed. By the tip of the last decade, after seeing the worth of these investments fall, legacy media corporations made it clear to digital media executives that they weren’t keen on being acquirers.

With no strategic purchaser out there, merging with one another utilizing publicly traded inventory might give VC and PE shareholders an opportunity to money out of investments that had been nicely previous the usual maintain time of seven years. Digital media corporations eyed particular function acquisition corporations — also referred to as SPACs or blank-check corporations — as a technique to go public rapidly. The recognition of SPACs picked up steam in 2020 and peaked in 2021.

Deal stream accelerated. Vox acquired New York Journal in September 2019. A couple of week later, Vice introduced it had acquired Refinery29, a digital media firm centered on youthful ladies. BuzzFeed purchased information aggregator and weblog HuffPost in 2020 after which acquired digital writer Advanced Networks in 2021 as a part of a SPAC transaction to go public. Vox and Group 9 agreed to a merger later that yr.

BuzzFeed, usually thought by business executives on the time to have the strongest stability sheet with the perfect progress narrative, efficiently went public by way of SPAC in December 2021. Shares instantly tanked, falling 24% of their first week of buying and selling. The approaching weeks and months had been even worse. BuzzFeed opened at $10 per share. The inventory presently trades at about $1 — a 90% lack of worth.

BuzzFeed’s underwhelming efficiency coincided with the implosion of the SPAC market in early 2022 as rates of interest rose. Different corporations that deliberate to comply with BuzzFeed shut down their efforts to go public utterly. Vice tried and failed. Now it is attempting for the second time in two years to discover a purchaser. BDG and Vox, in the meantime, deserted issues to go public. Vox as an alternative bought a 20% stake in itself in February to Penske Media, which owns Rolling Stone and Selection.

Consolidation was at all times a flawed technique as a result of digital media might by no means turn out to be large enough to compete with Fb and Google, mentioned Built-in Media’s Miller.

“You must have ample quantity of scale to matter, however that is not a profitable method by itself,” Miller mentioned.

Vice’s deal for Refinery29 is a main instance of a deal motivated by scale that lacked client rationale, mentioned BDG’s Goldberg.

“The digital media rollup has confirmed profitable solely when belongings are thoughtfully mixed with an eye fixed towards shoppers,” Goldberg mentioned. “In what world did Vice and Refinery29 make sense together?” 

Vice is engaged in sale talks with quite a lot of consumers that fall exterior the digital media panorama, CNBC beforehand reported. It is also contemplating promoting itself in items if there’s extra curiosity in components of the corporate, equivalent to its TV manufacturing belongings and its advert company, Advantage.

Vice is a cautionary story of what occurs to a digital media firm when its model loses luster, Miller mentioned. Valued at $5.7 billion in 2017, Vice is now contemplating promoting itself for round $500 million, in line with individuals conversant in the matter, who requested to not be named as a result of the sale discussions are personal.

A Vice spokesperson declined to remark.

“Within the previous days of media, with TV networks, if you happen to had been down, you would revive your self with a success,” mentioned Miller. “Within the web age, every part is so simply substitutable. If Vice goes down, the viewers simply strikes on to one thing else.”

Corporations equivalent to BuzzFeed, Vox and BDG at the moment are looking for a permanent relevancy amid a myriad of knowledge and leisure choices. BuzzFeed has chosen to lean in to synthetic intelligence, touting new AI-generated quizzes and different content material that fuses the work of workers writers with AI databases.

BDG has chosen to primarily goal feminine audiences throughout way of life classes.

Vox has centered on journalism and knowledge throughout quite a lot of completely different verticals. That is a technique that hasn’t actually modified even because the market has turned towards digital media, permitting Vox CEO Jim Bankoff the chance to proceed to hunt for offers. Simply do not count on the companions to be Vice, BDG or BuzzFeed.

“We need to be the main trendy media firm with the strongest portfolio of manufacturers that serve their audiences on trendy platforms — web sites, podcasts, streaming providers — whereas constructing franchises via a number of income streams,” Bankoff mentioned. “There isn’t any doubt M&A is a part of our playbook, and we count on it’ll proceed to be sooner or later.”

Whereas executives could also be making technique selections with a sharper eye towards the patron, the issue of discovering an exit for traders stays. Differentiation could open up the pool of potential consumers past the media business. BuzzFeed’s emphasis on synthetic intelligence might entice curiosity from expertise platforms, for example.

It is also attainable that there will probably be an eventual second wave of peer-to-peer mergers. Whereas Built-in Media’s Miller does not count on a future business rollup, BuzzFeed’s Peretti hasn’t closed the door on the idea if market situations enhance. As executives put money into fewer concepts and verticals, the tip end result may very well be more healthy corporations which might be extra enticing merger companions, he mentioned.

“If everybody invests in what they’re greatest at, if you happen to put them again collectively, you’d have that diversified digital media firm with actual scale,” Peretti mentioned. “That helps drive commerce for all components of a unified firm. I believe it is nonetheless attainable.”

Disclosure: Comcast’s NBCUniversal is the guardian firm of CNBC.

WATCH: Axios’ Sara Fischer on BuzzFeed’s persevering with struggles